Consolidate, Simply, Improve Your Finances

I have been helping a family member wrap her arms around her financial situation recently and thought I'd share my observations. Unlike the typical situation these days she has judicially salted away money every month for a very long time and therefore won't be wondering if she can maintain her lifestyle in retirement. But, her husband ran into some health issues two years ago and she had to take the reins of their finances for the first time in 20+ years. In their family, her accountant husband had a mind for numbers and had invested money with 15+ mutual fund companies, opening one or two funds at each. This caused paperwork nightmare for someone who is financially savvy, let alone someone who has problems balancing the checkbook.
The health situation opened her eyes and woke her up to the fact that if something happened again she wasn't sure she would even know where all their money was. Of course, having 20 different mutual funds doesn't mean you are diversified. It's also a huge hassle. I've been enlisted to help them consolidate their accounts, re-balance and simply things. They are also looking into working with a financial planner. I'm admittedly not an expert on equities, bonds, and the like, but as the financial meltdown of 2008-2009 has shown, neither are most of the people on Wall Street. I'll list the steps I have taken below. They want to take a mostly DIY approach to their investments so I've tried to not make things overly complicated while bringing their risk down.
STEP ONE. CONSOLIDATE
As noted above, my relatives had holdings at over 15 institutions. While they had some real quality companies working for them, I question whether each of the offerings at T.Rowe Price, Vanguard, and Schwab have significant enough differences to spread your money around everywhere. This is especially true with the number of non-transaction fee funds and ETF's available at most full service discount brokers.
a) Where to consolidate?
This is essentially a personal preference since many of the brokers have similar offerings these days. My personal favorite is Fidelity, though Schwab is a close second. Both have a solid offering of branded no transaction fee funds, charge no annual fee, have relatively low minimums, and charge lower trading fees than many of their competitors. There are cheaper options for trading and lower minimums elsewhere, but these two have very good customer service in my experience which is worth the extra dollar or two on trades (since they are mostly invested in mutual funds).
There are also some very good mutual fund companies such as Vanguard and T.Rowe which basically have a brokerage account tacked on as an afterthought to their fund offerings. Both are great companies, but have thin offerings outside their branded funds.
After laying out the options they have decided to go with Fidelity.
b) Making the Move
One of the reasons that we settled on Fidelity was that quite a few of their funds were part of Fidelity's NTF network, so they could be rolled and moved into the brokerage account essentially unchanged. A number of the other offerings will be liquidated and moved into a similar offerings from the Fidelity branded funds, NTF funds Fidelity offers, or comparable ETF's. The whole process can be initiated online and finalized by mailing some paperwork to Fidelity. It is a fairly pain free process, but takes a little while.
STEP TWO. SIMPLIFY
Asset allocation is the single most important factor in this process and I haven't been able to find any online tools that I feel confident with. This is especially true given the huge differences in allocations each recommended. My relatives are about 5 years from retirement, so they will need a more conservative allocation than someone like me. I have recommended that my relatives visit a financial planner who charges hourly and schedule an appointment to review their goals and get a plan figured out. A few hundred dollars is a small price to pay for solid advice.
STEP THREE. IMPROVE
While things haven't been finished yet. They are off to a good start. The final pieces will fall into place once they meet with the financial planner. I believe they will benefit a great deal from having the vast majority of their investments under one umbrella and just a few funds at another broker. Now, if something happens at least all their money will be in one place and accessible if necessary.
I'm interested to hear if you have had an experience good, bad or otherwise moving things under one roof. Do you have any other advice for them? If so, email me.
Image Credit: Ben30 @ Flickr
As a DIY investor without a broker, I have been looking around (for a while now) trying to find a tool that will help me allocate my investments in different asset classes and help me rebalance them occasionally. As I will probably elaborate on in an upcoming post, I haven't really been happy with any of the tools that I've tried so far. The tools have either been too simplistic, way too complicated, or the numbers just don't seem to add up. I should note that I have been trying out free tools, when I probably just should have broke down and pay for some advice.


Last month the national debt clock maintained by the Durst Organization in NY ran out of digits. The United States debt exceeded $10 trillion dollars and the clock's dollar sign had to be removed and replaced with another digit. The clock will soon add two more digits... here's to hoping that's something we never have to use.
Floyd Norris had an article two days ago that listed the worst months for the market in U.S. history. I'm not a believer that the stock market is a barometer for the overall health of the economy (I think the stock market operates on momentum and emotion, where the economy tends to slog forward or backward with fewer rapid ups and downs), however it is interesting to see how this crazy month has stacked up historically. It should be noted that the
File this under the "obvious" category. The
We've heard the stories about how bad the topsy-turvey student loan market has gotten for consumers, but I recently was able to witness things first hand. In an attempt to consolidate a couple private student loans to make things more convenient, I was only able to find two lenders still offering private consolidation loans (Citi and Key). To make matters worse, the lenders wanted approximately 8% and near 9% respectively for an applicant with excellent credit. The game plan now has moved to not consolidating and paying private loans off as quickly as possible.
Boston Consulting has released its most recent Global Wealth Report and it has some information that is probably pretty surprising to most Americans. The report has statistics on where the highest concentrations of millionaires are located in the world. The surprising part for me was which country was on top... Singapore. In Singapore apparently 1 in 10 households have assets in excess of $1 million dollars. The list below has stats on what percentage of the population is worth more than $1 million in each of the top five countries:



Now that it is looking more and more likely that Pres. Bush's economic stimulus package will in fact be made a reality as early as next month -- raining down checks of $300 to $1,200 per household.. What do you plan on doing with your check? I plan on investing the money (I suppose that shouldn't come as a surprise since I blog about being cheap). Sorry to those of you expecting me to do my part to get this economy back on track - hopefully other people carry my weight for me.